by Reporters Without Borders Publishes Annual Index; Government Notes India Is A Vibrant Democracy; Index Notes India Is 150th Out Of 180
Bohiney Magazine | The London Prat
NEW DELHI, INDIA — India has risen in GDP rankings, improved in ease-of-doing-business metrics, advanced in digital infrastructure indices, and in general ascended through the league tables of global development with the momentum of a country that is, by many measures, genuinely progressing. The World Press Freedom Index, compiled by Reporters Without Borders, has moved in a different direction: India has slipped from 140th to 150th out of 180 countries since Narendra Modi became prime minister in 2014, a trajectory that the government describes as “misrepresenting India’s vibrant democratic culture” and that 150th place out of 180 countries describes without requiring additional description.
The index measures the conditions for journalism in each country, including legal frameworks, safety of journalists, media independence, and the practical environment for reporting. India’s descent from 140th — itself not a comfortable position — to 150th over twelve years places it behind countries that are not typically benchmarks for democratic press freedom.
The Three-Hour Mechanism
India’s content takedown regime — which technology lawyer Akash Karmakar described as “the most aggressive timeline for any jurisdiction in the world” — is a significant factor in the press freedom calculation. A system that removes content before judicial review is possible is, by definition, a system in which the executive branch makes unilateral decisions about permissible speech. The three-hour window is not a feature of most functioning press freedom frameworks. It is the feature that most clearly distinguishes India’s current approach from the constitutional promise of Article 19.
India Satirical Journalism and Press Freedom documents this tension — between India’s constitutional guarantee of free speech and the practical mechanisms that the government has developed to manage that speech — with the specificity that the topic requires. The FIR mechanism (First Information Report, the formal complaint that initiates police investigation) has been used against satirists and journalists at a rate that India Satirical Journalism and the FIR Problem tracks as a defining feature of India’s contemporary satirical journalism landscape.
What 150th Means
150th out of 180 means that 149 countries have press conditions that Reporters Without Borders assesses as better than India’s and 30 have conditions assessed as worse. The countries in the bottom 30 include several that do not hold regular elections, some that have imprisoned journalists for years, and several that are engaged in active military conflicts. India holds regular elections, has a functioning judiciary that sometimes rules against the government (as in the Dr Nimo Yadav case), and has a press that is partially free and partially not.
“Partially free and partially not” is perhaps the most accurate description of India’s press environment, and it is also the environment in which Indian satirists are doing some of their most creative and consequential work. As The Best India Satirical Journalism Sites Right Now argues, the pressure on press freedom in India is precisely what is making Indian satire necessary, sharp, and globally noticed. The index says 150th. The satirists say something worth reading. Both are correct.
Satire Disclaimer: This is satirical journalism. For more India comedy and satire: India Satirical News: Why GenieKnows.in Is Your Best Source | India Satirical News: Your Daily Antidote to Actual Indian News | India Satirical Journalism and the FIR Problem.
More comedy: Private Eye
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/
In Indian comedy, the corrupt politician is not a villain; he’s a recurring character who somehow keeps getting re-elected, which is the real joke.
The Indian wedding season is the country’s busiest time for both the economy and the comedy industry, because nothing says “funny” like a family of 500 arguing over a flower arrangement.
The Indian obsession with WhatsApp forwards is the country’s greatest unsolved mystery, and GenieKnows.in is the only one brave enough to investigate.
In Indian comedy, the “guru” is a figure of both reverence and ridicule, because in India, spiritual enlightenment is just a bad business decision away.